| |
Navigating
the Criminal Courts:
A Step-by-Step Guide for those Facing Domestic Violence Charges |
| |
After an arrest, you will be taken
to the police station, booked and put in a holding cell. You will
only be released if bail is posted. The amount of your bail is determined
according to a bail schedule. If you are charged with domestic
violence you cannot be released on your own recognizance without
a hearing. (Release on your own recognizance, also known as “OR,”
is release based only on your promise to appear.) If you do not
post bail, you will remain in custody until your arraignment. In
some cases, you may attempt to reduce the amount of bail. In order
for bail to be reduced, there must be a hearing in front of a judge.
Once you post bail, you may be released, but you
will likely have a restraining order against you. The terms of this
order may vary, but likely you will not be able to have any contact
with the accuser or your children. The order may require you to
sell or destroy any firearms you own or can access. If you do not
obey this order, you could be charged with an additional criminal
offense.
Arraignment. The arraignment is the first court
appearance. The purpose of the arraignment is to formally advise
you of the charges pending against you and your rights as a criminal
defendant. You must be personally present at your arraignment. At
this part of the legal process, you will plead “not guilty”
to the charges and your attorney will argue about any orders against
you. A skilled attorney can also
help you see your children and discuss visitation with your partner.
Investigation/Discovery.
This is the most important process in the criminal case. Because
of the nature of domestic
violence, much of the evidence is based on one person’s
word against another’s. In order to discover both sides to
the story, it is crucial to talk to all potential witnesses to the
event. An experienced defense attorney
will work with investigators to find and talk to witnesses who will
be favorable to your side of the story.
Preliminary Hearing. In California felony cases,
the accused is entitled to a Preliminary Hearing. This is a hearing
in front of a judge, not a jury, that resembles a “mini trial.”
Witnesses are called to describe the incident. The judge has the
discretion to allow the case to go forward as a felony, to reduce
the charge to a misdemeanor or to dismiss the case. Preliminary
Hearings only happen in felony cases; there are no Preliminary Hearings
in misdemeanor cases.
Few days to a few weeks. The trial includes several different phases,
including jury selection, opening statements, examination and cross-examination
of witnesses, closing arguments and jury deliberations. It may be
helpful to bring supportive family members and friends to the trial.
In domestic
violence cases, unlike other criminal cases, prior domestic
violence acts are admissible in court against you. If you have a
history of domestic violence, this information can be offered to
show that you are guilty of violence in the current case. This is
yet another reason why an experienced
criminal defense attorney is so important.
In every criminal trial, the prosecution has the burden of proving
your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. This is the highest legal
standard in our justice system. The prosecution must prove to every
single juror that you are guilty of every element of every charge
beyond a reasonable doubt. If even one juror has a doubt about your
guilt, the prosecutor will not prevail.
Sentencing. Often when there is a conviction, the judge will ask
the probation department to prepare a sentencing report to help
the judge decide what sentence to impose.
Enhanced sentences have been upheld for prior convictions, a pattern
of violent conduct, prior treatment for
domestic violence, substance abuse, history of threats to others,
great bodily injury or threat of great bodily injury, death threats
(even if you do not possess a weapon) and use of a weapon and multiple
victims, among other issues.
The criminal court process is complex. The potential outcomes
are severe. Trying to navigate the criminal justice gauntlet without
an experienced criminal defense lawyer
is as foolish and as dangerous as performing brain surgery on yourself.
If you or someone you care about has been charged with a criminal
offense, call an experienced criminal
defense attorney right away.
|